The hiker and the two shepherds
A man is hiking in the mountains and comes across two shepherds who are about to eat. He asks if he can share their meal, and the shepherds agree. The first shepherd has 7 cheeses and the second has 5. The three of them sit down and each eats four cheeses. To pay them back, the hiker gives them €12. The first takes €7 and the second takes €5.
Is that a fair split?
No, the split is not fair. The first shepherd had 7 cheeses and ate 4, so he gave away 3. The second shepherd only gave the hiker one (he had 5 at the start but ate 4). The hiker paid €12 for 4 cheeses, which works out at €3 per cheese. So the first shepherd should get €9 and the second only €3.























































